Virtualization is Not the Cloud
An Analysis of the Gaps Between Virtualization and Cloud Computing
If you’re considering extending your use of virtualization technology to improve utilization of your computing resources, you may have heard that virtualization accomplishes the same goals as cloud computing. Not true.
Virtualization is not the cloud. There are significant gaps between the capabilities of virtualization and the cloud. Virtualization is a way to make better use of your infrastructure, but it doesn’t come close to the level of elasticity, empowerment, self-service, and automation of the cloud. Ultimately, with virtualization, you’re still in the infrastructure business.
This paper analyzes the benefits of cloud computing, side-by-side with virtualization, and establishes why they are not interchangeable. If you want user empowerment, scalability, and relief from the burdens of maintaining hardware and software yourself, you want the cloud.
Benefits of Virtualization
Virtualization emerged in the mainframe era as a practical solution to help IT departments make better use of their investments in enterprise-grade hardware, such as high-performance computers, servers, and storage. These machines could handle more workload than a typical application required, so the idea of running virtual machines, each performing discrete tasks, on a single piece of hardware, was appealing.
“Client/server done right.” In a way, virtualization is the last bastion of client/server technology. It has made that paradigm more efficient; think of it as “client/server done right.” The virtualization universe ekes some additional value from enterprise-level architectures, concepts, and cost structures and makes running an IT estate operationally smoother. But fundamentally, it is still very much about deeply integrating applications with infrastructure, albeit with an additional layer of software that masks these distinctions.
Heavy duty. Virtualization nets benefits for enterprises with significant investments in traditional technologies such as large relational databases, virtual local area networks, multiterabyte servers, and storage area networks. The emphasis is on persistence and stability, and to a large degree, it was achieved.
New tools. Over time, tools were added to make administration of the virtual machines easier, such as templates, controllers for starting and stopping services, and centralized administration. Until recently, virtualization has not been very flexible, especially when it comes to enterprises’ need to scale up or down quickly or to provision resources.
Privacy. For organizations with significant security requirements and a need for dedicated resources, virtual machines can replicate the required level of resource or device privacy and control that comes with hard-wired devices.
Customization. As virtualization is based on dedicated in-house resources, the potential for customization is extensive.
Drawbacks of Virtualization
While the idea of “virtualizing assets”—reassigning computing power to maximize efficiency of physical hardware—is a concept that virtualization and cloud computing share, virtualization falls far short of the promise of cloud computing.
Virtualization does not offer self-service, choice, or empowerment. As an enterprise deployment, virtualization is complex and requires a high degree of centralized control, which
means business users or departments can’t simply “virtualize at will” and provision their own resources. A request still must be sent to IT, which adds time, when users could be spending that time innovating and experimenting.
Virtualization technology is not elastic. A typical virtual machine environment is in place almost as long as a traditional client/server implementation and is almost as difficult to deploy and retract. Starting and stopping services, and removing artifacts of virtual machines from hardware when they are no longer needed, is time-consuming and can result in costly errors. The license model doesn’t support on-demand computing. Virtualization makes better use of computing power, but it still relies on a licensing model that mirrors enterprise software licensing, which can get very expensive, fast. To save money with virtualization, enterprises must first have expensive equipment in-house, which is then logically subdivided. Licenses can’t be turned on and off like a utility, which negates some of the value of the on-demand computing proposition of virtualization.
You are still in the infrastructure business. Although you can get better bang for the buck out of your hardware with virtualization, you are still responsible for acquiring, managing, and replacing that hardware. IT staff still need to apportion the servers, administer change requests, and be responsible for the same patches, upgrades, and vendor roadmap concerns that traditional enterprise computing customers do.
Your IT department still has to be “jack of all trades and master of none.” A virtual machine could save you money on hardware through improved server utilization, but you still have to have someone on staff who can intervene if your applications break. That goes for every other application you have—including virtualization itself. You’re giving your capital expense a rest, but your human resources still have as much work as ever.
Virtualization does not equal automation—at least not automatically. It is possible to automate a virtualized infrastructure with certain additional tools, but they don’t come out of the box.
Virtualization addresses only one pillar of IT service: Infrastructure. Virtual machines are a good example of Infrastructure-as-a-Service (IaaS), but they don’t supply two other critical services that make enterprise computing run better: Platform-as-a-Service (PaaS) and Softwareas- a-Service (SaaS). Your enterprise is still on the hook for buying and managing hardware and software.
Virtualization doesn’t boost security. While cloud providers have beefy security certifications for their data centers, it’s a myth that virtual machines are inherently more secure than physical hardware. Securing 100 virtual machines requires the same amount of effort and diligence as securing 100 servers.
Virtualization was made for IT. Ultimately, virtualization was introduced to lower expenses and make life easier for IT, but not necessarily for everyone else. Because it is largely invisible or opaque to business users, it doesn’t encourage self-service or pushing the boundaries of computing power to create new products and services.
The Advantage of the Cloud
If your goal is to reduce technology cost, empower users, enable self-service, and get out of the IT infrastructure business, the answer lies in the cloud. Virtualization takes you only a small part of the way there.
The cloud automates management. Fundamentally, the cloud’s value is in automation. Virtualization was about moving from directly managing physical resources to managing virtual resources on top of physical resources. The step from virtual to cloud is a bigger and more fundamental transition. In the cloud, you can eliminate a high percentage of the IT tasks you used to have with on-premise equipment. Your equipment lives offsite, maintained by someone else. Through automated routines and application program interfaces, provisioning and managing resources is a snap. The cloud is largely self-managing and self-healing.
The cloud distributes control. With virtualization’s centralized control model, the organization still depends on one or two people sitting at a console. In the cloud, you can provide access to any number of developers and business users. IT managers can see, at a glance, exactly which applications are running where and how much computing power (therefore, how much money) they’re consuming—and take action if that needs to change. Can you do that in your enterprise now?
The cloud scales. Today, you might need 10 servers. Tomorrow, you might need 100. Because cloud providers have spent years building out data centers with highly scalable hardware, the cloud can accommodate wide swings in demand. Through easily accessible portals, you can switch services on and off, without having to submit a work ticket or wait for approval.
The cloud empowers. The cloud empowers users to innovate, using massive amounts of commodity hardware, housed at secure data centers offsite. You don’t have to wait for IT to
locate and apportion computing power within your enterprise’s finite resource base. If the marketing department wants to test a website concept (or five) with real market participants, they should be able to spin it up directly and immediately and switch it off as soon as the experiment is over. The faster you can access computing power when you need it, the faster you can innovate, without spending a lot of money.
The cloud supersedes virtualization. Conceptually, cloud computing and virtualization are similar. Both logically separate hardware, software, and user interface functions. Some cloud
services, such as IaaS, use virtualization as a delivery mechanism. But the cloud continues where virtualization leaves off. With the cloud, you get infrastructure (IaaS), development platforms (PaaS), and applications (SaaS) delivered as a service, and the daily grind of maintaining those resources is no longer your problem. Virtualization is a layer of software on top of your existing resources, which you must continue to maintain. The cloud removes the burden of maintaining those resources, and scales them infinitely, for you to use a service, when you need it. Don’t let anyone tell you they’re interchangeable.
Private clouds can support virtualization. A managed private cloud provides dedicated infrastructure that can scale to your specific computing, bandwidth, and storage needs, fully supporting your virtual machines. Operating systems and application platforms are fully customizable. In a managed private cloud, you can get customized virtual hardware allocation and license renewal, round-the-clock data center support, the option to add resources when you need them, and service-level agreements. A managed private cloud can offer the best of both worlds.
Deciding Between Cloud and Virtualization
If you’re trying to decide what’s right for your environment, here’s table that can help you.
Virtualization is a layer of software that improves the management of the resources you already have. It conserves resources and makes some aspects of computing operationally smoother, but it doesn’t relieve any of the responsibilities of IT. In fact, it adds one—managing virtualization itself. Nor does it provide self-service, elasticity, or automation for business users and developers.
Fundamentally, with the cloud, you’re paying to use resources, located elsewhere, as a service. That means automation, user-friendly access, a full accounting of what’s running where and how much it’s costing you. With the cloud, you have a low-cost, robust, secure resource that expands when you need more of it and contracts when you need less. You’re out of the infrastructure business and back where you belong—in the innovation business.
The cloud is as much a philosophy as a technology, and it’s quite different from the philosophy that informs virtualization. The two should never be confused, but that doesn’t mean they can’t be combined. Managed private cloud services combine the flexibility of the cloud with the dedicated resources and customization capabilities of virtualization.
Contributed by Rackspace Engineers and Jacob Walcik. Jacob Walcik is a enterprise architect on the Rackspace Cloud Builders team. Having been at Rackspace a little over five years, Jacob enjoys the technical challenges, working with brilliant people and helping customers.
© 2014 Rackspace US, Inc.
Except where otherwise noted, content on this site is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License
See license specifics and DISCLAIMER